Choosing an extraction method from the reactivity series
The diagram shows part of the reactivity series. Carbon and hydrogen are included for comparison. Q is a metal.
(a) Name a metal from the diagram that is found in the Earth's crust as the uncombined element.
(b) Suggest how metal Q is extracted from its oxide. Explain your answer.
(c) Explain why magnesium cannot be extracted by heating magnesium oxide with carbon, and state the method that is used instead.
- 1
(a) Metals at the very bottom of the series are so unreactive that they do not combine with oxygen or other elements, so they are found uncombined. Gold.
- 2
(b) Q is below carbon in the series, so carbon is more reactive than Q. Heating the oxide of Q with carbon (coke) reduces it: carbon removes the oxygen and the metal is left.
- 3
(c) Magnesium is above carbon — it is more reactive than carbon, so carbon cannot remove oxygen from magnesium oxide. Metals above carbon are extracted by electrolysis of a molten compound.
- 4
The general rule: the more reactive the metal, the more stable its compounds and the harder (and more energy-consuming) it is to obtain the metal from its ore.
Answer
(a) Gold (b) Heat the oxide with carbon — Q is below carbon, so carbon is more reactive and reduces the oxide (c) Magnesium is more reactive than carbon, so carbon cannot reduce magnesium oxide; electrolysis (of a molten compound) is used.
Examiner tip
The June 2025 examiner report noted that, while stronger candidates were correct, others chose electrolysis as the process for extracting iron from hematite, when it is reduction with carbon (monoxide). Electrolysis is only needed for metals above carbon; a metal below carbon is always reduced with carbon because that is far cheaper.