Picking out isotopes from nuclide symbols
The symbols of five atoms, A to E, are shown.
(a) Which three atoms are isotopes of the same element?
(b) Explain, in terms of subatomic particles, why these three atoms are isotopes of each other.
(c) Which two atoms have the same number of neutrons?
(d) Atoms B and C have the same nucleon number. Explain why they are atoms of different elements.
- 1
In a nuclide symbol the top number is the nucleon (mass) number, the total of protons and neutrons, and the bottom number is the proton (atomic) number.
- 2
(a) Isotopes of one element have the same proton number. A, C and D all have proton number (nickel), so A, C and D are isotopes.
- 3
(b) Isotopes are atoms of the same element with the same number of protons but different numbers of neutrons. Here A, C and D each have protons but have different nucleon numbers, so different numbers of neutrons.
- 4
(c) Number of neutrons nucleon number proton number. Work it out for every atom:
- 5
C and E both have neutrons. (d) An element is defined by its proton number. B has protons (cobalt) and C has protons (nickel), so they are different elements even though their nucleon numbers are the same.
Answer
(a) A, C and D (b) Same number of protons () but different numbers of neutrons (c) C and E ( neutrons each) (d) They have different numbers of protons ( and ).
Examiner tip
A common error is to define isotopes only as "atoms with different mass numbers". The two marking points are same number of protons (same element) and different number of neutrons — state both. Never say isotopes have a different number of electrons: neutral atoms of isotopes have the same number of electrons.