Sorting bars into magnets, magnetic and non-magnetic materials
A student has three metal bars, J, K and L, and a bar magnet with its poles labelled. She brings one end of each bar close to the N pole and then to the S pole of the magnet. Her results are shown.
| Bar | Near the N pole | Near the S pole |
|---|---|---|
| J | attracted | attracted |
| K | repelled | attracted |
| L | no force | no force |
(a) State which bar is a permanent magnet. Explain how the results show this.
(b) State what bar J is made of, in general terms.
(c) Suggest a material that bar L could be made of.
- 1
(a) Only a magnet can be repelled by a magnet, because repulsion needs two like poles facing each other. Bar K is repelled by the N pole, so the end of K that was tested must itself be an N pole. Bar K is the magnet.
- 2
Attraction on its own proves nothing: a magnet attracts both a magnet (unlike poles) and an unmagnetised piece of magnetic material. That is why the repulsion is the deciding result.
- 3
(b) Bar J is attracted by both poles. It has no poles of its own, so it is an unmagnetised magnetic material (for example iron). Each pole of the magnet induces an opposite pole in the near end of J, so J is always attracted.
- 4
(c) Bar L feels no force from either pole, so it is a non-magnetic material, for example copper, aluminium or brass.
Answer
(a) K — it is repelled by the N pole, and only a magnet can be repelled. (b) An unmagnetised magnetic material (e.g. iron). (c) A non-magnetic metal such as copper or aluminium.
Examiner tip
A common error is to say that J must be a magnet because it is attracted. Attraction happens between a magnet and any magnetic material, so only repulsion proves that an object is a magnet. Write the reason, not just the letter.